physics-based method
PoseX: AI Defeats Physics Approaches on Protein-Ligand Cross Docking
Jiang, Yize, Li, Xinze, Zhang, Yuanyuan, Han, Jin, Xu, Youjun, Pandit, Ayush, Zhang, Zaixi, Wang, Mengdi, Wang, Mengyang, Liu, Chong, Yang, Guang, Choi, Yejin, Li, Wu-Jun, Fu, Tianfan, Wu, Fang, Liu, Junhong
Existing protein-ligand docking studies typically focus on the self-docking scenario, which is less practical in real applications. Moreover, some studies involve heavy frameworks requiring extensive training, posing challenges for convenient and efficient assessment of docking methods. To fill these gaps, we design PoseX, an open-source benchmark to evaluate both self-docking and cross-docking, enabling a practical and comprehensive assessment of algorithmic advances. Specifically, we curated a novel dataset comprising 718 entries for self-docking and 1,312 entries for cross-docking; second, we incorporated 23 docking methods in three methodological categories, including physics-based methods (e.g., Schrödinger Glide), AI docking methods (e.g., DiffDock) and AI co-folding methods (e.g., AlphaFold3); third, we developed a relaxation method for post-processing to minimize conformational energy and refine binding poses; fourth, we built a leaderboard to rank submitted models in real-time. We derived some key insights and conclusions from extensive experiments: (1) AI approaches have consistently outperformed physics-based methods in overall docking success rate. (2) Most intra- and intermolecular clashes of AI approaches can be greatly alleviated with relaxation, which means combining AI modeling with physics-based post-processing could achieve excellent performance. (3) AI co-folding methods exhibit ligand chirality issues, except for Boltz-1x, which introduced physics-inspired potentials to fix hallucinations, suggesting modeling on stereochemistry improves the structural plausibility markedly. (4) Specifying binding pockets significantly promotes docking performance, indicating that pocket information can be leveraged adequately, particularly for AI co-folding methods, in future modeling efforts. The code, dataset, and leaderboard are released at https://github.com/CataAI/PoseX.
Autonomous Golf Putting with Data-Driven and Physics-Based Methods
Junker, Annika, Fittkau, Niklas, Timmermann, Julia, Trächtler, Ansgar
Abstract--We are developing a self-learning mechatronic golf robot using combined data-driven and physics-based methods, to have the robot autonomously learn to putt the ball from an arbitrary point on the green. Apart from the mechatronic control design of the robot, this task is accomplished by a camera system with image recognition and a neural network for predicting the stroke velocity vector required for a successful hole-in-one. To minimize the number of time-consuming interactions with the real system, the neural network is pretrained by evaluating basic physical laws on a model, which approximates the golf ball dynamics on the green surface in a data-driven manner. Thus, we demonstrate the synergetic combination of data-driven and physics-based methods on the golf robot as a mechatronic example system. With the aid of autonomous robots, the everyday life of many people should be made easier in the near future, e.g., by For this, a prudent action of the autonomous robot is essential.
A physics-based method that can predict imminent large solar flares
The sudden release of magnetic energy on the Sun drives powerful solar flares, which are difficult to predict. Kusano et al. derived physics-based thresholds for the onset of large solar flares and show how they can be predicted from routine solar observations (see the Perspective by Veronig). They tested their method using observations of the Sun from 2008 to 2019. In most cases, the method correctly identifies which regions will produce large flares within the next 20 hours, although there are some false positives and false negatives. The method also provides the exact location where each flare will begin and limits on how powerful it will be. Accurate predictions of solar flares could improve forecasts of space weather conditions around Earth. Science , this issue p. [587][1]; see also p. [504][2] Solar flares are highly energetic events in the Sun’s corona that affect Earth’s space weather. The mechanism that drives the onset of solar flares is unknown, hampering efforts to forecast them, which mostly rely on empirical methods. We present the κ -scheme, a physics-based model to predict large solar flares through a critical condition of magnetohydrodynamic instability, triggered by magnetic reconnection. Analysis of the largest (X-class) flares from 2008 to 2019 (during solar cycle 24) shows that the κ -scheme predicts most imminent large solar flares, with a small number of exceptions for confined flares. We conclude that magnetic twist flux density, close to a magnetic polarity inversion line on the solar surface, determines when and where solar flares may occur and how large they can be. [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.aaz2511 [2]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abb6150